Planned Independent Requirements - Versions

[former_member475608]

Dear

Gurus,

I'm trying to create PIR(md61) for a single material on the same date but with 2 separate quantities. System is not letting me. Both quantities cannot be added but need to be separately planned. As far as my research goes there are 2 solutions: Defining 2 separate Versions or defining 2 Requirements Plan. I am unable to do both as the info on this topic is limited on scn. Can someone please help me out with detailed solution with screen shots.

Thanks

shankar

[solomon_macwan]

Hi Shankar,

It is strange that I have created requirement on the single date with requirement type vsf with different production version. but still system is creating single plan order for all of them.

Ideally if the production version is different than it should create different plan order. I think you should raise it to SAP. Please see below screenshots.

regards,

Solomon

[Mahendran8888]

Hi Shankar

     Using MD61 create demand for first required qty, run mrp, convert in to the Prd ord or Pur ord or STO. Again keep same materail create qty, get pld ord running mrp, convert it to Order. Same process do for two times for getting seperate orders.

[former_member475608]

Hi

solomon,

Yes thats what im saying.

Thanks
shankar

[solomon_macwan]

Hi Shankar,

I have given 2 different production version on the same date. so according to the production version I was expecting different plan order. but system is creating single order with the first production version.

Hope you raise this to SAP.

regards,

Solomon

[former_member184574]

Hi Shankar,

Not sure why you want to put two different requirements for the same material on the same date. Can you elaborate the business requirement for this and very curious to know this kind of requirement.

Are you working on MTS or MTO. ?

if it is MTO scenario, then this requirement is logical and can be done easily in SAP. If you are working on MTS then this requirement is illogical and cannot be met in Standard SAP.

Sit with your client, understand the requirement in detail, then explain and convince them on this .

Hope this helps.

Thanks

Kumar

[former_member475608]

hi

kumar

its Mts. my client has 2 assembly lines and he want to plan one fert material on both assembly lines in one go. for that im using Prodversions. Pir are being generated separately but after mrp run planned orders get clubbed. How to unclub them?

thanks

shankar

[milton_gallegos]

Hello Shankar.

In a MTS scenario usually PIR is unique for a point on time. If you want allocate the production to many assembly lines you can use  Quota arragementes for production version. You can get more information here:

• Quota Arrangements - Master Data (PP-MRP-BD) - SAP Library

Best regards

Milton

[former_member261747]

Hi Jayesh

                I think you can not achieve your requirement through PIR in standard. But you can achieve this with CIR. Which is MTO Scenario.T-Code MD81 > MD50>MD04

[former_member185450]

Hello Shankar,

Production version:

but same date two different quantities will not be possible as system will check the date and consider the greater one as a demand.i.e. same date two schedule lines will not be possible through production version demand

Case 2 : As suggested requirement type. the requirement type will depends on the planning strategy which you have maintained in the material master..

in this case you can upload the demand for same material with same date by using the two different requirement types,

Regards,

Venkatesh..

[solomon_macwan]

Hi Shankar,

Setting up a different requirement plan is much simpler and convinent solution for this.

regards,

Solomon

[former_member475608]

Hi

Solomon,

Can you kindly elaborate how will I go about this solution? Can you guide me in detail with screen shots from the beginning, as I have never used this or configured it?

Thank you

Shankar

[former_member185450]

Shankar,

Through requirement plan with two active versions also we can upload the demand

Regards,

Venkatesh..

[solomon_macwan]

Hi Shankar,

As Venkatesh has suggested, enter the requirement plan and material no and MRP Area and qty .

regards,

Solomon

[former_member475608]

Hi

Venkatesh,

I tried this solution and PIRs are being generated separately, thankyou for that. BUT MRP run is clubbing together both Independent requirements and creating a single Planned order. What I want is that MRP Create 2 Separate Planned orders for the 2 seperate IndReq.

Any luck on that?

Regards
Shankar

[former_member475608]

Hello

MRP run is clubbing together both Independent requirements and creating a single Planned order. What I want is that MRP Create 2 Separate Planned orders for the 2 seperate IndReq.

Thanks

Shankar

[milton_gallegos]

Hello Shankar

I was wondering if you can share with us what is the businnes scenario that you are trying to map in SAP. It's a make to order or make to stock scenario?. Standar system have different functionalities, however we need more information to suggest one of them.

You can have different requeriments for a material at the same date. For example you can recibe Sales Order from different customers for the same delivery date. Do you want create one procuremet proposal for each sale order?

In the material master you can assign  Checking Group  for availabilty check = 02 Indiv. requirement . The system creates one procurement proposal for each individual requirement.

Best Regards

Milton

[former_member475608]

Hi

Milton,

It's make to stock scenario. I just checked in MRP 3 veiw and its already maintained availability check = 02 Indiv. requirement.

But it's still not making individual planned orders.

How to solve this?

Thanks

shankar

[milton_gallegos]

Hello Shankar

Could you share wich planning strategy are you using?

Milton

[former_member475608]

strategy 10

thanks

shankar

[sandeep_praharaj]

Hi,

Are your both the version are active version kindly check.

Active versions are considered during MRP run. If you have more than one active version all  versions will be treated as requirements and will be used to generate planned order, one use of this would be to use different requirement types .

Other use would be to have like draft copy of PIRs before finalizing the active version.

Thanks & Regards

Sandeep Kumar Praharaj

[former_member475608]

Hi

Sandeep,

I have not created any versions as of yet. Can you please help me out with this solution in detailed with screen shots, as I have never worked on Versions or Requirement Plans before thanks.

Ill gladly award you full points for your efforts

Regards
Shaknar

[sandeep_praharaj]

Hi,

Please do the following

Select requirement plan option give any description than inside enter relevant material

save .

similarly you can enter N no of plans, after that you can do the planning.

Thanks & Regards

Sandeep Kumar Praharaj

[former_member475608]

Hi

I did this and PIRs are being generated separately. BUT MRP run is clubbing together both Independent requirements and creating a single Planned order. What I want is that MRP Create 2 Separate Planned orders for the 2 seperate IndReq.

Thanks

shankar

[former_member194456]

Hello

I think if you are using the MTS scenario than system will not create the separate planned orders for the same date requirement.

Have a look on the note for question 6 .

https://launchpad.support.sap.com/#/notes/550568

And also on the document for the BAdI

Hope this may help

Regards

SS

[former_member194456]

Hello

I hope the PIR version will solve your problem.

Please try yourself with the same material with the different PIR versions in MD61.

Use standard version is suggested (define your own version in OMP2).

Also please note that if you mark version active than only the system will plan the PIR in the MRP run

Hope this may help

Regards

SS

[former_member475608]

Hello

SS,

So what I understand I should use a standard version on the same material for first quantity on the same date and then use another standard version on the same material for the second quantity on the same date?

Kindly clarify and elaborate what other steps are required prior and after this?

Thanks

Shankar

[former_member194456]

Hello

I hope the std version will serve your requirement

Have a look on the screen shot

MD61 - maintain the details in versions

Run the MRP - MD02 for the material. Have a look in MD04 for the requirement

Hope this may help

Regards

SS

[former_member475608]

Hi

SS

As you can see MRP run is clubbing together both Independent requirements and creating a single Planned order. What I need is that MRP Create 2 Separate Planned order for the 2 IndReq.

Any luck on that?

Thanks

Shankar