O'toole's Irish Pub & Grill

This bar is legit when it comes to food. Wayyyyyyy better than rooster. If you thinking about going to rooster you better off here. I went on superbowl Sunday and the waiter was so good she didnt even write our order down and didnt get anything wrong. She was super on point. The set up of the bar is cool too. During the game the entire bar was rocking. Best thing ever.

Customer service was fantastic. Cassandra was our bartender and she was great and very friendly. She was 100% on top of things. Drink pours were fantastic. Definitely not a craft beer place. I wouldn't consider this place a sports bar. Wings were cooked well but lacked flavor. I would give the wings a 4.8-5.1/10 range. I would consider this more of a drinking spot.

I can say you won't see those views anywhere near Columbus Ohio, but I like the vibe for sure!

Be careful of the new bartender Raven.... You might end up with multiple drinks you didn't ask for on your tab. I had 2 Jack & Cokes, which she charged for then felt the desire to also charge me for 2 Henny's.... I don't even like Hennessy! She's new and doesn't know the ethics of bartending. She thinks she'll just pocket the $19 as an extra tip, my guess... If she's there, save yourself the time/money and just leave. She's cute, but not professional.

I love being there the people and food are just so nice. My favorite food is there subs and pizza really good stuff. Need to come down and enjoy all the fun and excitement.

Went for for a work Happy hour with a group of about ten. I didn't order food but several of my co-workers did and they were raving about the Italian sub. (~$8 with a side of fries) I tasted the pizza which was pretty good...crunchy crust, nice cheese topping and these mushrooms...so different from the norm...I guess they marinate them there. And they're not quite crunchy but kinda almost.

The bartender/server, Cassandra did a great job of taking care of our group and the rest of the bar. They had a couple bourbon choices for me but limited on the draft choices, however my bud light was very cold.

Decent neighborhood bar! It's been around for a long time. Also, the other patrons (the regulars) did not seem bothered with our big group and were actually friendly unlike some neighborhood places.

Before I open the front door, I'm greeted by an a-frame chalkboard on the sidewalk announcing O'Toole's daily food special: steak & egg pepper jack melt with cole slaw & fries. $6.95. The awesomeness begins washing over me like a hot shower after a long walk on a cold day.

I open the door. Early live Black Sabbath pours out into the parking lot. I pause a moment to transition from the hot, brightly sunlit day and clamoring W. Broad St traffic to the cool, dim, inviting space ahead.

Whatever I had been thinking about before instantly evaporated in an invisible mist of newfound contentment.

Just inside the door, another chalkboard announced the formation of a pool league and an upcoming dart tournament (O'Toole's has 4 pool tables & 2 dart boards in a separate room).

The bar is kind of shaped like a bow tie, but sized for a 200-foot-tall Pee Wee Herman. (Now there's a scary thought!). So, the bar-setters generally face each other. It's hard not to get at least casually engaged with the group.

The beer ($2) was cold, the food was hot, the music was enjoyably varietal, the servers were friendly, and the clientele was cheerful.

In that, you have the real 5 stars of a place like O'Toole's, or almost anywhere worth going.

Decent food, decent prices, small menu, weird music, interesting vibe, cute waitress.

food-better off at a fast food joint nearby. dress code-really? place is not that great. boys with saggy pants and baseball caps galore. not much in way of drinks. terrible draft selection unless you really really like miller lite.