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¡RUM†RF 3\WKLD WKHRQO\WKUHH RFFXU +GW WKHVHDUHLQIDFW W KH LQ W KH H QWLUH PDVVLYH WH[W RI +LVWRULHV RIWKHWHUP UHQFHV .W¡RUM$RF LVIUHTXHQWO\ WKLVXVDJHLVDPHWDSKRU 7KHIDFWWKDW JORVVHGRYHUE\ ,ZRXOGOLNHWR LQWUDQVODWLRQ ,QFRQWUDVW DQGHIIDFHG FRPPHQWDWRUV DQGH[SORUHLWV WDNHVHULRXVO\ WKHPHWDSKRULFDO FKDUJHRI./¡RUM$RF ,ZLOOQHHGWRFRQVLGHU LQRUGHU WRGRWKDW VRPHWKLQJ LPSOLFDWLRQV RIWKHFRLQDJHV\VWHP RIOHJDO RIWKH*UHHNV RZQ  FRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQ FRLQ .W¡RUM$RF+RZ WHQGHU[4UMAD[D´µNLOX[ DQGFRXQWHUIHLW   WKH*UHHN RIWKHVHWZRLOOXPLQDWH WKHVWUXFWXUDO PLJKW RSSRVLWLRQ  HWDSKRU FXOWXUDO RIRUDFOHV"+HURGRWXV P SURYRNHVWKH LPDJLQDU\ R UDFOHV  FRXQWHUIHLW" $UH W KHUH RWKHU ZKDW PDNHV ZD\VLQ TXHVWLRQV 7KHUH XQ LQ+HURGRWXVWH[W LVDOVRDVLQJOH RFFXUUHQFH  RID.L¡RUM$RF PHDQLQJ WRUHIHU $WKHQLDQV WRWKHLU DGXOWHUDWHG RUJXLOHOHVV XVHGPHWDSKRULFDOO\ OR\DOW\ E\WKH FDQGHVLJQDWH HLWKHU DGXOWHUDWHG FDXVH+GW¡ 7HFKQLFDOO\ WRWKH*UHHN .L¡RU $RF IURP ZKLFK 3ROOX[ JORVVHV PHWDO RUFRXQWHUIHLW FRLQVLQFHLWLVGHULYHG LG¡RRF ,ZLOOEHDUJXLQJ WKDW WKHWHUP DVGURVV RUDOOR\RIJROG,QHDFKFDVHLQ+HURGRWXV LQ )RUWKHPHDQLQJ RIWKHVHWHUPV RIFRLQDJH ZLWKLQ WKHFRQFHSWXDO VSKHUH RSHUDWHV 0RQ«WDLUH HQ'DDUPHH -+DQJDUG VHH/6-VZ.L¡RUM$HLD JHQHUDO .L¡RU_$RF .L¡RRF DQG35DGLFL &DOWDELDQR 9HQYDQWH  0&DFFDPR 0HWDIRUHQ *URQLQJHQ GRNLPRQ WRG HQDQWLRQ &RODFH$UJXULRQ SDUDV¬PRQ3ROOX[ $613VHU 'XHSDVVLQHOOHVVLFRPRQHWDOH   6$OHVVDQGUL HGLQ .L¡RUM$RF   IRU +HURGRWXV  3HORULWDQD GHL3HULFRODQWL $WWL GHOOD$FFDGHPLD WRUQL  $OHVVDQGUL  RIWKHWHUP WRRUDFOHV VHHLQSDUWLFXODU DSSOLFDWLRQ 7KXVIRU $GH6«OLQFRXUW 7KH+LVWRULHV >/RQGRQ @  ^+HURGRWXV H[DPSOH WKHDPELJXLW\ RIWKLVRUDFOH+GW WKH/DFHGDHPRQLDQV IDLOHG WRSHUFHLYH WUDQVODWHV LWLQKLVRZQIDYRXU WKHDPELJXRXV DQVZHU DUULYHG >&URHVXV@ LQWHUSUHWHG  ZKHQ RIFHUWDLQ ZKLFK KDYH DQGEHJDQWKHZDU+GW RQWKHVWUHQJWK RUDFOHV 5:DWHUILHOG WREHDVZLQGOH  +GW /LNHZLVH ^+HURGRWXV SURYHG DWDQGDQGIDOVHRUDFOHV 7KH+LVWRULHV >2[IRUG @ RIIHUV DPELJXRXV 7KH+LVWRU\&KLFDJR UHSUHVHQWV +HURGRWXV DW  ' *UHQH RUDFOHDQG KHWUDQVODWHV WKHSKUDVH DWDQGDVIDOVHFRLQ WKHH[FHSWLRQ DVWKRVH VLPSO\ IDOVHFRLQ DQVZHU   ZKLOHUHQGHULQJ UHVSHFWLYHO\ RUDFOHVZHUHIDOVH   This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions  /(6/,(.85.( RUDFXODU ZKLFKRUDFOHVDUHOLNHFRLQV",IVRZKDWZRXOGFRQVWLWXWH OHJDOWHQGHU" RIWKHSKUDVH UHYLHZWKHVHWKUHHRFFXUUHQFHV %XWOHWXVILUVW PHWD  FRXQWHUIHLW RUDFOH$WILUVW JODQFHHYHQ+HURGRWXV WKUHH 7KH QDUUDWRU XVHV WKH I RUPXOD D  XVHVVHHP GLVSDUDWH JURXS SKRULFDO RI&URHVXV FRQVXOWDWLRQ WZLFHLQWKHIDPLOLDU  VWRU\ ;47>2>L¸F .L¡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¡EU DFS $ œFUXYRL MS LQEDWWOH ZRXOGHQVODYHWKH7HJHDWHV%XWZRUVWHG KRZHYHU DOLYHZHDU PDQ\RIWKHPZHUHFDSWXUHG KDGERUQHDQG WKDW WKHPVHOYHV WKH\ LQJWKHVKDFNOHV WKH ZHUHZRUNLQJ DURSHWKH\ >LW@RXWZLWK PHDVXULQJ +GW  SODLQRIWKH7HJHDWHV LQEDWWOH ZRUN WKHSODLQRI7HJHDDV GHIHDWHG 7KXVWKH6SDUWDQV 0RUHIDPRXVO\ WKH'HOSKLF RZQVKDFNOHV VODYHVERXQGZLWKWKHLU LIKHFURVVHVWKHULYHU RUDFOHWR&URHVXVWKDW +DO\VKHZLOOGHVWUR\ DW D [4+A´©.L¡RUM$RF D JUHDWHPSLUH LV E\+HURGRWXV  GHVLJQDWHG WKHPRPHQW &URHVXVODXQFKHVKLVLOOIDWHG DJDLQVWWKH H[SHGLWLRQ 3HUVLDQV+GW  ZDVERWK &URHVXVEODPLQJ &\UXVIRUWKHVHWKLQJV PDNHDQ WRWKHRUDFOHV>WRDVN@LIKHVKRXOG VHQGLQJ ZKHQ WKH DQG 3 HUVLDQV HVSHFLDOO\ DJDLQVW H[SHGLWLRQ RUDFOHFDPH £LL.2_D«YRX WKHFRXQWHUIHLW ;4AA WKDW WKHRUDFOHZDVRQKLVVLGH .L¡RU_†RXH[SHFWLQJ  RI DQH[SHGLWLRQ ZDVPDNLQJ DJDLQVWWKHDOORWPHQW WKH3HUVLDQV +HUHDQGWKURXJKRXW IURP DOOWUDQVODWLRQV *UHHN XQOHVVRWKHUZLVH LQGLFDWHG DUHP\RZQ 7KLVRUDFOHLVRIFRXUVH LQ RIDPELJXRXV XWWHUDQFH $ULVWRWOH 3DUDGHEHLVSLHO V WKH5KHWRULF D  This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions &RXQWHUIHLW2UDFOHV DQG/HJDO 7HQGHU  +HURGRWXVILQDO  XVHRIWKHWHUP IRUDQRUDFOHRFFXUV .L¡RUM$RF LQ%RRNDQGVHHPVWRPHDQVRPHWKLQJ $W TXLWHGLIIHUHQW RIWKH6SDUWLDWHV LQD VSHHFKSXWLQWKHPRXWK WKDW WKH\FRPSODLQ ,QFLWHG RXWIURP E\IDOVHRUDFOHV.L¡¸UM$RLRL _XDY[U_/RLDLZHGURYH  WKHLU KRPHODQG PHQZKRZHUHPRVW RXU[HQRLDQGZKRKDGXQGHUWDNHQ WRUHQGHU $WKHQV DQGZKHQ ZHKDGGRQHWKLV ZHKDQGHG VXEVHUYLHQW WKHFLW\RYHUWRWKHXQJUDWHIXO GHPRV 7KHRUDFOHVUHIHUUHG WR KHUHDUHWKHUHSHDWHG ZKHQHYHU WKH6SDU LQMXQFWLRQV E\WKH3\WKLD WDQVFDPHWRFRQVXOW WKHRUDFOHRQDQ\EXVLQHVVSXEOLFRUSULYDWH WKDW V KRXOG I LUVW IUHH $WKHQVDV+HURGRWXV WHOOVXVDW  WKH\ WRWKH$WKHQLDQ WKH3\WKLD GRHVEHFDXVHVKH 7KLVDFFRUGLQJ DFFRXQW KDVEHHQVXERUQHG FDVK7KXVLQWKLVRUDFOHIUHH E\$OFPDHRQLG  .L¡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¡RUM$RF KHUHVHH-( 3RZHOO$/H[LFRQWR PHDQLQJ +HURGRWXV&DPEULGJH +.OHHV'LH(LJHQDUW GHVJULHFKLVFKHQ  VYLG¡RU_$RF *ODXEHQVDQ2UDNHOXQG6HKHU 7¾ELQJHQ )RUP  +5 ,PPHUZDKU DQG7KRXJKW LQ+HURGRWXV&OHYHODQG Q,GRQRWILQG WKH FRQYLQFLQJ  ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQV FRXQWHUFODLP RI.+.LQ]O+HURGRWRV 5K0QV>@ KHUHDVDWDQGDQGWKDW Q  WKDWWKHZRUGKDVWKHVDPHPHDQLQJ LWLVOHVVHPEDUUDVVLQJ IRUWKH6SDUWDQV WRFODLPWKDWWKH\ KDYHEHHQGHFHLYHGE\ RUDFOHVUDWKHU WKDQ IRROHG RUDFOHV PLVOHDGLQJ E\IRUJHG )RUJHQHUDO RQWKHSROLWLFDO DQGV\PEROLF RI FXOWXUDO DUJXPHQWV VLJQLILFDQFH LQDUFKDLF DQGFODVVLFDO*UHHFH VHH(:LOO'HO DVSHFW«WKLTXH GHVRULJLQHV FRLQDJH GHODPRQQDLH 5HYXHKLVWRULTXH   5«IOH[LRQV HWK\ JUHFTXHV This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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ª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¾Q]EO¦WWHU DXV$WKHQ 6FKZHL]HU =ZHL.OHLQP¾Q]HQ E\ 3£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«IOH[LRQV DERYH JRHVEDFNWR:LOO'H O DVSHFW«WKLTXHDQG GLG$QFLHQW 6WDWHV6WULNH :K\ Q VHH.UDD\DERYHQ &-+RZJHJR &RLQV"1& +RZJHJRDERYHQ VHHDOVRH[WHQGHG LQ.XUNH &RLQVDERYHQ  DUJXPHQWV This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 7(1'(5 $1'/(*$/ 25$&/(6 &2817(5)(,7  $WWKHVDPHWLPHWKHDYRLGDQFHRIWRNHQFXUUHQF\ JXDUDQWHHG FRQYHQWLRQDO WKHTXDOLW\ RIFRLQVDQGFLWL]HQV ZDVQRW WKDW  PHUHO\ WRWKHLU QDWXUH %XWKHUHZHIDFHDQRWKHU EXWHVVHQWLDO SDUDGR[RI VLOYHUFRLQ VLWXDWLRQ $WKHQLDQ VLOYHU 7RIRFXV MXVWRQWKH$WKHQLDQ WLPHVDQG SXUHDQGUHOLDEOHDQG\HWLQDQFLHQW DJHZDVIDPRXVO\ ZLWKRXW WR WHVW WKH RI VLOYHU LWLVDOPRVW VWLOOWRGD\ TXDOLW\ LPSRVVLEOH 79%XWWUH\ WKHREMHFWXQOLNH JROG $VWKHQXPLVPDWLVW GHVWUR\LQJ LQ REVHUYHG GHWHUPLQH WKH +RZGLGWKHGRNLPDVWHV RIWKH ILQHQHVV FRLQSURIIHUHG" H[LVWHGLQ +HGLGQRW+HFRXOGQRW1RWHFKQLTXH WKH Q R H[LVWV DQG E\ZKLFK WHFKQLTXH WRGD\ DQWLTXLW\ RQWKHVSRW FRLQFDQEHGHWHUPLQHG ILQHQHVV RIVLOYHU 7KHWRXFKVWRQH ZLWKDQ\DFFXUDF\ SURYLGHG RQO\D RI QRWHVDUDQJHRIHUURU %RJDHUW JHQHUDO SRVVLELOLW\  LQWKH  LHDWRWDOSRVVLEOHHUURU RI s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£VDQRV 6RZK\GLG FLHQWWHFKQRORJ\ LQDPHWDO WKH$WKHQLDQV FKRRVHWRPLQW FRLQVRIUHPDUNDEOH SXULW\ WKDW FRXOGQRWEHWHVWHG" ,IWKH$WKHQLDQ DYRLGDQFHRIELPHWDOOLVP DQGWRNHQFXUUHQF\ DQDORJL]HVFLWL]HQDQGFRLQXQGHUWKHVLJQRISKXVLVWKHH[WUHPH RIDFFXUDWHO\ WKHTXDOLW\RIVLOYHUVSHOOHGRXWE\ GLIILFXOW\ WHVWLQJ  79%XWWUH\ 0RUHRQWKH $WKHQLDQ /DZRI %&1XPLVPDWLFD &RLQDJH HDQWLFKLW¢ FODVVLFKH  FLWLQJ 5%RJDHUW / (VVDLGHVPRQQDLHV GDQV 5HYXHEHOJHGHQXPLVPDWLTXH    O DQWLTXLW« This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions  /(6/,(.85.( ,DPVXJJHVWLQJ LQWKHGLUHFWLRQ RIQRPRV WKDW SDUD %XWWUH\SRLQWV  WKDW VLOYHU ZDVFKRVHQIRUFLYLFFRLQDJH GR[LFDOO\ SDUWRIWKHUHDVRQ LWVTXDOLW\ IRUWKLVLV RISURRILQJ EHSUHFLVHO\ WKHGLIILFXOW\ PLJKW LQWKH RIFRPPXQLW\ FRQVHQW ZKDWRSHQHGDVSDFHIRUWKHZRUNLQJV EHFDXVH Z DVFKU¬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¬PDWD IURP LVGHULYHG ¶«[RALDLVHH/6-VY•.L_DR© ·•.L_DR©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¬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his content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 2UDFOHVDQG/HJDO7HQGHU &RXQWHUIHLW  DPRPHQW $WKHQLDQ FRPPLWPHQW WRVLOYHURQO\ FXUUHQF\ UHSUHVHQWV  ZKHUHDPDWHULDO RU VHHPVRYHUZULWWHQ RIFXOWXUDO SUDFWLFH RSDFLW\ PR RULGHRORJLFDO ZHZRXOGFDOO LUUDWLRQDO RYHUGHWHUPLQHG E\ZKDW HYLGHQFH DQGDUFKDHRORJLFDO WLYDWLRQV $VZHNQRZIURP LQVFULSWLRQDO 5RPDQHUD %&( , VWKPLD WR IURP 'HORVFRXQWHU UDQJLQJ VL[WKFHQWXU\ LQWKHVKULQHV ZHUHRIWHQ DVVXFK IHLW RQFHLGHQWLILHG FRLQV GHSRVLWHG  LQWKH0HWUR¸Q LQ$WKHQV RI3RVHLGRQ WKHWHPSOH RIYDULRXVJRGV LQ 6RIRUH[DPSOH RI$SROORRQ'HORV RUWKHWHPSOH DW,VWKPLD WKH % &( WKH O DZRI DQ$WKHQLDQ GRNLPDVW¬V FLW\ V  FRLQDJH RIILFLDO WHVWHU RIFRLQVLVLQVWUXFWHG 526(*  ª¢Y´ªœL>µ[RF¢NRY@ RLD.RQ7H[FR QD>TDY7.@ I .L¡RUM$RY I œLR_WLµ‚XS”RY .DO D .DOªRUD OHT´YUTF0W@WT©>W@F·YeF·\ .>D[D¡D†@ ‚H[FR «©[I@ D ¡R$I_Y %XWLILWKDV>DEURQ]HFRUH@RUD OHDGFRUHRULV LW>LPPHGLDWHO\@ DQGLW KHVKDOOFXWWKURXJK FRXQWHUIHLW RIWKH0RWKHU RIWKH*RGVDQG VKDOOEHVDFUHG SURSHUW\ LWLQWKHFRXQFLO7H[W DQGWUDQVODWLRQ KHVKDOO>GHSRVLW@ *UHHN +LVWRULFDO IURP 3-5KRGHVDQG52VERUQH QR  % & >2[IRUG @   ,QVFULSWLRQV RI WKDWWKHODZPRYHGWKHVWRUDJH 7KHUHLVVRPHSRVVLELOLW\ WRWKH0HWUR¸Q RIWKH$FURSROLV FRLQVIURP WKHWHPSOHV FRXQWHUIHLW UHFRUGHG LQYHQWRULHV IURP WKHILIWK VLQFHVHYHUDO FHQWXU\ GHSRVLWV WHPSOH RQWKH$FURSROLV LWVHOI 2WKHU RIFRXQWHUIHLW FRLQVLQYDULRXV WHPSOHV WKLVSUDFWLFH RIGHGLFDWLQJ HYLGHQFH VKRZVWKDW VFDWWHUHG LQVFULSWLRQDO GLIIHUHQW DWPDQ\ FRXQWHUIHLW FRLQVWRWKHJRGVRFFXUUHG VLWHV H[WHQGLQJ ,QDGGLWLRQ LQWRWKH+HOOHQLVWLF DQG5RPDQSHULRGV DUFKDHRORJLVWV )RUWKLVSKHQRPHQRQ LQJHQHUDO VHH/ 5REHUW ‹WXGHVGHQXPLVPDWLTXH IDOVLQHOOHLVFUL]LRQL *OLVWDWHUL JUHFTXH3DULV '3HSSDV'HOPRXVRX ,WDOLDQRGL1XPLVPDWLFD   -5 $UPDOH GHOO ,VWLWXWR DWWLHQH %URQ]H 1&WKVHU YRO 1RWHVRQ+HOOHQLVWLF 0HOYLOOH -RQHV &RLQDJH (SLJUDSKLFDO $Q$WKHQLDQ /DZRQ6LOYHU&RLQDJH   56 6WURXG +HVSHULD LQ5&.QDSSDQG-'0DF,VDDF  5&.QDSS,QWURGXFWLRQ WR5REHUW ([FDYDWLRQV DW1HPHD ,,,7KH&RLQV%HUNHOH\ .QDSS  7KDQNV WRVHYHUDO RIWKHVH  IRU FDOOLQJP\DWWHQWLRQ   RIWKH+HFDWRPSHGRQ ,*LLOLQH ,QYHQWRU\ %&( ¢T\Y4LRY FRLQIURP WR(>‚@HXDLYµeY (OHXVLVVHH,*LL%OLQH FRXQWHUIHLW ./@¡RU_†RY OLQH,QYHQWRU\ OLQH>UHVWRUHG@,*LL OLQH>UHVWRUHG@  ¢J\¼@4LRY RIWKH7DPLDHRIWKH2WKHU *RGV%&( ¢4\œ4LR\ LG¡RU >†RY FRLQPL[HGFRLQIURP (OHXVLV 2QWKH (‚HL[MLYµI*HY FRXQWHUIHLW D¼_D_DeL.7RY LQWKHIRXUWK FIURP WKH$FURSROLV WRWKH0HWUR¸Q WKDW ZDVPRYHG VWRUDJH SRVVLELOLW\ VHH6WURXGDERYHQ   ZKHQ ZHILQG WKH 7KXV0HOYLOOH-RQHVDERYHQ DUJXHV WKDW SHUVXDVLYHO\ LQWHPSOH LQYHQ DERYHWKHGUDFKPD IRUFRLQVRIGHQRPLQDWLRQV [A$NR½© GHVLJQDWLRQ LQ$WKHQV DQG IURP WKH$VFOHSHLRQ WKH$FURSROLV WRULHVDV ZHGRLQLQYHQWRULHV IURP WKHDGMHFWLYH YDULRXV LQYHQWRULHV [ANR½© LVDQHTXLYDOHQW 'HORV WKDW WHPSOH IRU œLµ[D$.RX©  $QG/RXLV5REHUWDERYHQ GLVFXVVLQJ TXRWHIURP WKHFRLQVOLVWHG IURP %&(QRWHV WKDW 'HOLDQWHPSOH LQYHQWRULHV DPRQJ GDWLQJ IURP WKHWUHDVXU\ RI$SROORZHUHWZRFDWHJRULHV ¢4\YTµQDR[DVLOYHUSODWHG DQG WRFRXQWHUIHLWV PXVW UHIHU WLQ W KDW .D[7/[«4/YRY This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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«ORJLTXHGH'«ORV ;9,,, /HPRELOLHUG«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¸QZKLFKVHUYHGDV WKHVWDWHDUFKLYHIRUSXEOLF VHH57KRPDV2UDO IURP WKHODVWGHFDGHRIWKHILIWK GHFUHHVDQGGRFXPHQWV FHQWXU\ 5HFRUGLQ&ODVVLFDO $WKHQV&DPEULGJH   1RQHWKH 7UDGLWLRQDQG:ULWWHQ OHVVWKLVSUDFWLFDOH[SODQDWLRQGRHV QRWIXOO\DFFRXQWIRUWKHGHGLFDWLRQRINQRZQ LQPDQ\RWKHUWHPSOHVLQFOXGLQJWKRVHRQWKH$FURSROLVWKDWRI3RVHLGRQ FRXQWHUIHLWV DW,VWKPLDRU$SROOR RQ'HORV QRUIRUWKHVSHFLILFODQJXDJHRI1LFRSKRQ VGHFUHH FRLQDV /HRµYVDFUHGRUFRQVHFUDWH WRWKHJRG ZKLFKGHVLJQDWHVWKHFRXQWHUIHLW This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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¬V EHWKHLPSHUDWLYH ´LD.2L7e7FR LQVFULSWLRQ DFWXDOFRLQILQGV  OHWKLPFXWDFURVV)RUDVZHNQRZIURP LQ$WKHQV DQGHOVHZKHUH WKHSUDFWLFH ZDVWRPDUN WKHFRXQWHUIHLW E\ D WKH F RLQ DQG WKHGLYLQH FXWWLQJ GHHSJDVKWKURXJK RIWHQ WKURXJK  7KXVWKLVZDVQRWVLPSO\ DQLPDJHRIWKHJRGUHWXUQHG WR LPDJH DQGPXWLODWHG WKHJRGEXWDGHOLEHUDWHO\ GHIDFHG LPDJH 6R,ZRXOGOLNHWRVXJJHVW DQDOWHUQDWLYH VWUXFWXUDOLVW LQ DFFRXQW ZKLFKLWLVQRWMXVWWKHLPDJHRQWKHFRXQWHUIHLW FRLQWKDWVLJQLILHG  RUUDWKHU EXWDOVRLWVVXEVWDQFH WKHPLVILW EHWZHHQ VXE GHFHSWLYH ,QWKHVHWHUPV ZHPLJKW VHHFRXQWHUIHLWV DQG VWDQFH DQGFLYLFVWDPS  6WURXGDERYHQ   )RUWKLVH[WUDRUGLQDU\ VFKROLDDG JROGLVVXHVHH$ULVWRSK )URJVZLWK ORF FLWLQJ +HOODQLFXV DQG3KLORFKRUXVPRGHUQ GLVFXVVLRQV LQFOXGH :(7KRPSVRQ  7KH*ROGHQ1LNDLDQGWKH&RLQDJHRI$WKHQV 1&WKVHU  .UDD\ DERYHQ +RZJHJRDERYHQ   ,*LLOLQHVOLQHVOLQHV WRDQG%& (UHVSHFWLYHO\IRU WKHVHODVWWZRLQYHQWRULHV GDWLQJ  GLVFXVVLRQ VHH/ 5REHUW 0RQQDLHV GDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQV 5HYXHQXPLVPDWLTXH VHU JUHFTXHV    ¯URUWKHPHDQLQJ R¯RLD.RUW7H7FR VHH6WURXGDERYHQ WRULOOXV WUDWLRQV RIVXFKGHOLEHUDWHO\ GHIDFHG FRLQVVHH6WURXGDERYHQ 3ODWHDI This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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” ¢Y´S´©\YF·YDL RX´«Y \D$HUFFR[HSRY .L¡RI_$RX ªD[LeTO L$«RYR© .¼TY R»´ HX$D¡LUMF .DL¢S\œ428 ¢YR[H[´©D[U  ;49RRY NO ´W@$ROR .DLªeHX4eOY ¢Y´SLDRFSFMM 4TW´LRY .œ4YH HO´ª S¯$RX YµR©¢Y´S´©HYLRW[ 4]RRL $H$U_7@ e2 9”•$O29´  e9O>!4eMOYIM724A@ L-M8”4”‰ ;2;2e”‰ .O¡2UM$27D;29,2/U &e ¡42;2ODL9 [R½[ ¢YWUM4•[D[RY 7L£Y[FRY .DL\YF·YDL   7KJQ LVFRXQ W KDQ D PDQ Z KR WR NQRZ LVKDUGHU 1RWKLQJ PRUH F DXWLRQ QRUGRHVDQ\WKLQJ WHUIHLW >WKDQ UHTXLUH JROGDQGVLOYHU WKLV@7KHGHOXVLRQRIFRXQWHUIHLW DQGHDVLHUIRUDZLVHPDQWR LVHQGXUDEOH .\UQRV %XWLIWKHPLQGRIDPDQZKRLVDIULHQG GLVFRYHU QRWLFHEHLQJIDOVHDQG LQKLVEUHDVW HVFDSHV>\RXU@ WKLVLVWKHPRVW LQKLVEUHDVW KHDUW KHKDVDWULFN\ DQG WKHJRGKDVPDGHIRUPRUWDOV FRXQWHUIHLW WKLQJ WRILQG RXW RIDOOWKLQJV WKLVLVWKHPRVWJULHYRXV UHIHU KHUH GRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\ NLEG¬ORV $V%$YDQ*URQLQJHQ QRWHV R I DVDQ NLEGRV 3ROOX[ WRFRXQWHUIHLW DOOR\ J ROG   JORVVHV FRLQDJH <HWWKH DGXOWHUDWHG FRXOGGHVLJQDWH VRNLEG¬ORV JROGRUVLOYHU VLPSO\  WRWKH0HWUR¸Q  UHIHUULQJ VHH'LQDUFKXV RIWKLVQRWLRQ )RUDQH[DPSOH WKHGHFUHHDJDLQVW ZLWK WKHSHRSOHDQGSURSRVHG PDGHDQDJUHHPHQW >'HPRVWKHQHV@ RIDOOZULW RIWKH*RGVZKRLVWKHFLW\ VJXDUGLDQ WREHNHSW KLPVHOI E\WKH0RWKHU WKLV IRU EHLPSLRXV WHQFRQWUDFWV ,WZRXOGWKXV \RXWRLQYDOLGDWH  LQH[WDQW RILG¡RU_$RF WKHROGHVW RFFXUUHQFHV XVZLWK SURYLGHV 7KHRJQLV SHUKDSV VHH%$YDQ*URQLQJHQ RIWKHWHUP KHUH *UHHNVHH7KJQ)RUWKHPHDQLQJ This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions &RXQWHUIHLW2UDFOHV DQG/HJDO 7HQGHU  UHYHDOV WKDWWKHLPDJH DQGODQJXDJH RIWKHSRHW VWKRXJKW PRYHPHQW Q RW RIDFRUUXSWHG LQWKHVH LVWKDW R I O LQHV FRLQDJH V LPSO\ LPSOLFLW ZLWK WKHLQGLVWLQJXLVK LVQRWFRQFHUQHG PHWDOOLF DOOR\)RU7KHRJQLV RIJRRGDQGEDGTXDOLWLHVLQWKHNDNRVDQ¬UEXWZLWK DEOHPL[LQJ DQDS DWKRURXJKO\ EDVHLQWHULRU KHDUWRUVRXO FRQFHDOHGEHQHDWK RID W KH LVQRW W KDW 7KDW L VWR QREOH V XUIDFH VD\ SDUDGLJP SDUHQWO\ DGXOWHUDWHG FRLQIRUPHG DOOR\EXWWKDWRIDFRXQWHUIHLW FRQVLVWHQWO\ DQDQLPD RIEDVH WHFKQLFDO IURP DSOXJ RULQPRGHUQ SDUODQFH 7KLV ZLWKLQ DVOLSRIJROGRUVLOYHU RUOHDG FRQFHDOHG PHWDOFRSSHU LQ W KH Y HUEDO VWUXFWXUH RI W KHVH LWV F RQILUPDWLRQ ILQGV WKHPDWLF SDUDGLJP WKHSRHW VDQ[LRXVUHODWLRQ LQWKHLU ZRUGRUGHU ZKLFKUHIOHFW YHUVHV 7KHOLQHVWKDW GHVFULEH FRXQWHUIHLW FRQFHDOHGLQWHULRULW\ WRDQRWKHU V EXWDV PHWDOVSURFHHGLQD OXFLGVHTXHQFHRIQRXQDQGDGMHFWLYH WKDW VRRQDVWKHSRHWWDNHVXSWKHWRSLFRIKXPDQ FRXQWHUIHLWLQJ ´ µ‚LRY HQFORVHV W KH  YµR© VXVSHFW VW\OHFKDQJHV FSL$RY ¢Y´4•© ZLWKLQ KLV DQGHYHQWKHJRG Hµ© OXUNV KLGHVªYFSSHDLY IM724 1RWLFH PRVWFRXQWHUIHLW FUHDWLRQWR½WR ./¡2UM†R[D7RY  LQSDU KHUHLWLVWKHJRGZKRPDNHVFRXQWHUIHLWV WLFXODU WKHUROHVDVVLJQHG DQGIDWKRP WKHWULFN IRU PRUWDOV DQGPDQZKRVHWDVNLWLVWRGLVFHUQ FRQVHFUDWHG NQRZQ FRXQ WKDW WKH*UHHNV 7KXV,ZRXOGVXJJHVW DQGVHSDUDWH WRFRQVWLWXWH WZRGLVWLQFW WRWKHJRGVLQRUGHU WHUIHLWV  WKHVSDFHRIWKHFLW\DQGLWVVXSHUQDWXUDO RXWVLGH ,IDW VSKHUHV ZDVFRXQ WREHWKHPDNHUV RIDOOWKDW VRPHOHYHOWKHJRGVZHUHIHOW WKHFRXQWHUIHLW LQKXPDQ WHUIHLW FRLQDFRQJHDOHG QXJJHW H[SHULHQFH W RWKHP RIGHFHSWLYH 7KXVWKLVSUDFWLFHRI EHORQJHG H[SHULHQFH RUPXWXDO WKHIXQGDPHQWDO GHGLFDWLRQ LQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\ UHJLVWHUHG EXWLWDOVR RIWKHZRUOG RIWKHJRGVDQGWKHVSDFHRIWKHFLW\ RSDFLW\ YDOXH WKHFLW\ VXOWLPDWH WRRYHUVHHDQGDGMXGLFDWH DVVHUWHG DXWKRULW\ LQ I URP D IHQFHG RII WKH WKH Y DOXH RI FLWL]HQ ZRUWK  VSDFH LQFOXGLQJ 7KLVZDVWKHVSDFHRIFKU¬PDWD RIGLYLQLW\ GRNLPD DUELWUDU\ ZRUNLQJV LQDQGV\PEROL]HG WKHKXPDQ ZKLFK SDUWLFLSDWHG JRRGVLOYHU FRLQDJH /H3UHPLHU /LYUH$PVWHUGDP   DG7KJQ VHH+DQ 7KHRJQLV DQG 0DQLQ')%ULJKW JDUGDERYHQO '%/HYLQH&RXQWHUIHLW (65DPDJH DQG7KHLU7UDGLWLRQV 6WXGLHV LQ+RQRURI&5 HGV&ODVVLFDO7H[WV LVXVHGWRGHV YDQ*URQLQJHQ 7UDKPDQ NLEG¬ORV &KLFR&DOLI &RQWUD FRLQVHH6WURXGDERYHQO  YDULRXV NLQGV RIFRXQWHUIHLW LJQDWH JHQHULFDOO\ DQG5DGLFL&RODFH DERYHQO  6HH$OHVVDQGULDERYH &DFFDPR&DOWDELDQR LQWKLVSDVVDJH RQWKHLGHDRIGHFHLWRUGXSOLFLW\ QO ZKRSXWVWKHHPSKDVLV RIZRUGV RIWKHNLEG¬ORV RI7KHRJQLV DQGLQRWKHU RFFXUUHQFHV IDPLO\  WRKDYHEHHQSUDFWLFHG IURP 2Q*UHHN ZKLFK FRXQWHUIHLWLQJ WHFKQLTXHV DSSHDU 7UDLW« HWURPDLQHV WKHHDUOLHVW GHVPRQQDLHV %DEHORQ 3DULV PLQWLQJVHH(  JUHFTXHV LP$OWHUWXP 1XPLVPDWLVFKH -*UDI 0¾Q]YHUI£OVFKXQJHQ  Y  RO, 5($,  FROO   .5HJOLQJ 6XEDHUDWXV =HLWVFKULIW 3UREOHPV LQ$QFLHQW ,PLWDWLYH XVHIXO DQGWKHUHFHQW YHU\ VXUYH\ E\3*YDQ$OIHQ LQ=+$UFKLEDOG DQG&RXQWHUIHLW -.'DYLHVDQG9*DEULHOVHQ HGV &RLQDJH %& DQG0DQDJLQJ 7KH1HZ:RUOG (FRQRPLHV 0DNLQJ RI$QFLHQW 0RYLQJ WKDWFRLQDJHLVDW PDNHH[SOLFLW 2[IRUG  )RUSDUDOOHOSDVVDJHVZKLFK LVOLQNHG ZLWK %'. ZKHUH NLEG¬ORV IU LVVXHVHH'HPRFULWXV DJDWKRSKDQ¬VDQG  WKHVWDPS LQFRQMXQFWLRQ (XU0HGHD ZKHUH NLEG¬ORV ZLWK FKDUDNW¬U DSSHDUV WKHEDVHNHUQHO RQDFRLQ 7KHQXPLVPDWLF WHFKQLFDO WHUP DQLPDXVHGWRGHVLJQDWH WRKDYHQRDQFLHQW RIDFRXQWHUIHLW FRLQ XQIRUWXQDWHO\ DSSHDUV SUHFHGHQW This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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¬VFRXOGQRWFXWWKHFRLQXQWLOKHGHWHUPLQHG E\RWKHUPHDQVLWVSUHVXPHGWUXH  WKHFRLQ SKXVLVRIZKLFKLQIDFWKHFRXOGQ WEHVXUHXQWLOKHFXWLQWRLHGHVWUR\HG LWLVWRNQRZWKHFRXQWHUIHLW PDQ 7KHRJQLV   LVFOHDUDERXWKRZGLIILFXOW ZKLOH7KXF LQGLFDWHVWKDWDPDQ V WUXH SKXVLVLVQ WUHYHDOHGXQWLOKH VEHHQ WKHUHPD\EHDERXWSKXVLV FXWDQGNLOOHGRQWKHEDWWOHILHOG:KDWHYHUSUHVXPSWLRQV PDQDQGFRLQERWKZLWKLQFRQWH[WV WKLVLVRQO\UHYHDOHGE\FXWWLQJNLOOLQJ UHJXODWHGE\ WKDWUHOLHYHVWKHWHQVLRQ RIWKLVUHYHODWLRQD FXWWLQJ QRPRL3HUKDSVLWLVWKHVDQFWLW\ IRUWKHJUHDWHUJRRGWKDWLVSUHVHUYHGE\GHGLFDWLQJWKHZDUGHDG DQG RIXQFHUWDLQW\  LQD VSHFLDOW«PHQRV WKHGHPRQLWL]HG / 0DXUL]LR DQG+LVWRUL $XWKHQWLFLW\ 'HOSKLF2UDFOHVDV2UDO3HUIRUPDQFHV LVLQWHQGHGWRFRXQWHUWKH FDO (YLGHQFH&$    0DXUL]LR VDUJXPHQW DQGDVVXPSWLRQVRIWKHROGHUVWDQGDUGZRUNVRQWKH'HOSKLF2UDFOH+ PHWKRGRORJ\ :3DUNHDQG' ( ::RUPHOO7KH'HOSKLF 2UDFOH YROV 2[IRUG DQG- )RQWHQURVH7KH'HOSKLF 2UDFOH %HUNHOH\  This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions &RXQWHUIHLW2UDFOHV DQG/HJDO 7HQGHU   LQFRQVWDQW LQWKHVH 2UDFXODU FRQFHLYHG WHUPV FLUFXODWLRQ DQG UHVSRQVHV  UHSUHVHQW DXWKHQWLFDWHG WKDW XVHGWKHP DFXUUHQF\ E\WKHFRPPXQLW\ PXFK WRFLYLFFRLQ RIFRLQDJH /LNHWKHSXUHVLOYHU YHU\ DQDORJRXV EXWFDQRQO\EHDXWKHQWLFDWHG WKHYRLFHRIWKHJRGLVSUHFLRXV E\ FRPPXQDO FRQVHQW $QGLQGHHG DVZHNQRZIURP VHYHUDO RFFXUUHQFHV LQ+HURGRWXV DQGHOVHZKHUH WKHWHFKQLFDO WHUP IRU DQRUDFOH DFFHSWLQJ DVJHQXLQH LV´«[R_QDLWKHYHUEIURP ZKLFK WKHDGMHFWLYH LV ´µNL_XR© 2UDFOHVEHFRPHOHJDOWHQGHU FKU¬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©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¬PDWD GRNLPD FRQFHSWLRQ 6HH+GW6RSK(O  $ULVWRSK 3ORXWRV,*LL This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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¢Y LQL WR°FWLQHLDLD[RD[¯´U©DL VFKHPLQJDJDLQVWWKH3HLVLVWUDWLGV +HURGRWRVGRHVQRWFKRRVHWRWHOOXVKRZLWKHOSHG ODUL[DYFµLDHYRL WKHP,QVWHDGKHEUDQFKHVRIILQWRD GLIIHUHQW VWRU\  Fµ©RRY WKH$OFPDHRQLGVEULEHGWKH3\WKLDWRZLQ $«\RXDLY ´I@RO$U_YD°R/ 6SDUWDQDLG+RZWKHQGLGWKHLUODYLVKSURYLVLRQRI3DULDQPDUEOH LQVWHDGRIWKHSUHVFULEHGOLPHVWRQHKHOSWKHP"2QO\VR IDUDV , DQGVR V JUDWLWXGH FDQ VHHLIWKHIDFWRIEXLOGLQJZRQWKH3\WKLD KHUWRVWLUXSWKH6SDUWDQVLQWKHVDPHZD\DVWKHEULEHU\ SURPSWHG ZDV VXSSRVHGWRKDYHGRQH7KDWLVWR VD\+HURGRWRVJLYHVWZR LQWKHRWKHUEULEHU\ YHUVLRQVLQRQHJHQHURVLW\ SURGXFHWKHVDPH UHVXOW 'HOSKLFVXSSRUW DWWRR¯$D.H´DL_DµYLRL RL$U_YD¯RL WKHQ IHHOVWKHQHHGWRHPHQG )RUUHVW 8QIRUWXQDWHO\ ZRXOGKDYHVDLGZKDW ZLWKZKRKHDFWXDOO\WKLQNV WRPDNH+HURGRWXV DFFRXQWFRQVRQDQW )RUUHVWLV ZDV RULJLQDOO\ SURSRVHGE\6FKZHLJK¦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£YDLH¯e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ª©[I@Y ULX¯U_Y [¢ªNWZY$‚.AHFRYL¶«FRY DJDLQVWWKHPDQGWKH3HLVLVWUDWLGV E\WKH3\WKLD LLDFS«D©[H.DL[R»©QHLDLD[4D[¯´D© ᒹ1RWLFH .DL[¢ªN[IM© QX*¯UM© ;( Q ;DYU [LYD RI WKDWWKHWKLQJVFRQWULYHG E\WKH$OFPDHRQLGDHFRXOGZHOOLQFOXGHWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQ WKHWHPSOHLQD ZD\ILQHUWKDQWKHSODQFDOOHGIRUDQGWKHUHVXOWDQW FRRSWLRQRIWKH WRHFKR KHUHVHHPVLQWHQGHG HVSHFLDOO\VLQFH[¢_DH_DU [mYUM>L«YD 'HOSKLFJRGKLPVHOI LVDOVRWKHSUREOHP DW FORVHO\OLQNHGWRWKHWHPSOHEXLOGLQJ7KHUH PK[DQmPHQRL  LQPHDQLQJWKHUHLVLIDQ\EHWZHHQª©[IMYQX7@YDQGLQL RFS«D© RIZKDWGLIIHUHQFH LQZKDWKDSSHQV VRPHGLIIHUHQFH .[$DW3HUKDSV+HURGRWXVLQWHQGVWRUHJLVWHU EXWLQQRUPDO*UHHN WRWKH3\WKLDDQGZKDWKDSSHQVWRWKH6SDUWDQVDQG3HLVLVWUDWLGV H©[LYDPHDQVFRQWULYH DJDLQVWVRPHRQHDV DW+GWVHH/6- XVDJH>LU@[DY£R>LD/ IURP $,  ,IZHDFFHSWWKLVXVDJHDQGDVVXPHWKDWWKHVKLIW VY>L7@[DY£R_ADL ª©WRLQL This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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©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¢ Le L7 [DYU A9 SOD\HG E\ ;  RQWKH3\WKLD DQGWKRVH WKH $OFPDHRQLGV RIWKH3\WKLD WKHPVHOYHV DQGWKH3HLVLVWUDWLGV  DJDLQVW 6HHHJ)-DFRE\ $WWKLV 7KH/RFDO&KURQLFOHV $WKHQV2[IRUG RI$QFLHQW  )RUUHVWDERYHQ 5KRGHVDERYHQ 7KRPDVDERYH GHU$ONPHRQLGHQ Q 0=DKUQW 'HOSKL6SDUWDXQGGLH5¾FNI¾KUXQJ =3(   7KHUHOHYDQW VRXUFHVIRUWKLVUHYLVHGVWRU\ RIWKHOLEHUDWLRQ IRXUWKFHQWXU\ RI$WKHQV DUH,VRFUDWHV'HPRVWKHQHV  ZLWKVFKROLDDG ORF  DQG'LQGRUI $WK3RO ) )*U+6FKRO$ULVWRSK 3KLORFKRUXV   /\VLVWUDWD  7KHVHWZRYHUVLRQV FRXOGEHFRPELQHG DVLQWKHDFFRXQW RI3KLORFKRUXV 6HH )RUUHVWDERYHQ 5KRGHVDERYHQ  1RWHDOVRWKDW+HURGRWXVVWRU\ KLV  KHUHGLYHUJHV LQVLJQLILFDQW ZD\VIURP RWKHU DFFRXQW RIWKHPDQLSXODWLRQ RIWKH'HOSKLFRUDFOHE\&OHRPHQHV SORWWLQJ DJDLQVW This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions  /(6/,(.85.( +HURGRWXVQDUUDWLYH  DOOWKHWXUQV 1RUKDYHZHH[KDXVWHG SHU $OFPDHRQLGV  IURP WKH WKDW GHULYH RUDFOHV FRXQWHUIHLW RQWKHVH IRUPV UHIHU WR ZLWK RQO\WKH6SDUWDQV EDUJDLQ $SROOR$V, QRWHG VWUDQJH WZRRFFXU WRWKHRWKHU WKHVHRUDFOHVDVFRXQWHUIHLW LQFRQWUDVW LQWKH ZKLFKERWKILJXUH UHQFHVRIWKHSKUDVH[47OrUOD´© .L¡RUM$RF W RWKH G RVRLQD PDLQQDUUDWLYH DQG UHSUHVHQWDWLYHV VSHHFK  WKH\ RI WKHLU RIWKHLU DOOLHVWRMXVWLI\ +LSSLDVDVW\UDQW SODQWRUHLQVWDWH ZULWODUJHDV DVDQDVVHPEO\ LVFKDUDFWHUL]HG 7KLVVHWWLQJ $WKHQV WKHPVHOYHV WKH6SDUWDQV H[SODLQ )RULWZDVIRUWKLVYHU\WKLQJWKDWZHVXPPRQHG WKHFLWLHVVRWKDWZLWK +LSSLDVKHUHDQG\RXIURP DQGFRPPRQ GHOLEHUDWLRQ FRPPRQ NRLYF,O  H[SHGLWLRQ KLP EDFNWR$WKHQV .DL.RLYFS D[R$TM OHDGLQJ  [H†R\&M/  ZKDWZHWRRNDZD\ ZHUHVWRUH +GW  WKH6SDUWDQVH[SOLFLWO\ RIFRPPRQGHOLEHUDWLRQ ,QWKLVVHWWLQJ DOOLHVLPSOLFLWO\ ZKLOHWKHLU WKDW DVVHUW WKHRUDFOHVZHUHFRXQWHUIHLW LW)RU I ROORZ IURP W KDW DFWLRQV WKH W KDW F ODLP DQG SURSRVHG UHMHFW WRWKH WKHDOOLHV UHDFWLRQ XVHVWRFKDUDFWHUL]H WKHYHUE+HURGRWXV RUDFOHVLV WKH E\FRXQWHUIHLW GHFHSWLRQ FODLPLQJ 6SDUWDQVVSHHFK   WKHVDPHYHUE LQ DVZHVDZIXQFWLRQV ZKLFK QHJDWHG YF´FNHWR  DQRUDFOHDVYDOLGRU WHUP IRUDFFHSWLQJ WKHVLPSOH[ DVWKHWHFKQLFDO R»N«YH´«.H[R [´L‚IMR© [F·Y ´ªDXPX£[FRY DXWKHQWLF [R»©$µ\RX©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¢YDWeH/ RUDFOHIURPWKHSURPDQWLV3HULDOODµ´ª.R¡FRYULH4LD$$DY[UMYL4•>DDY[LY [¢ .$HRA«YU_©H¡RX$H[R$«\HF7DL $«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his content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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­WLRQ ODQJXDJH SURSKHV\LQJ 6RFOHVGHVLJQDWHV WKHRULJLQDO RUDFOHWRWKH%DFFKL /DEGDWRW\UDQQ\ DGV¢DUPRYDQG¢]«.>[D47RY LQFRPSUHKHQVLEOH LQGHFLSKHUDEOH  LWLVSXWWRJHWKHU ZLWK WKHODWHURQHWR(­WLRQ+GW¡\O  XQWLO   &\SVHOXVJURZQWRPDQKRRGUHFHLYHVIURP'HOSKLDQ FXWVERWK ZD\V  SURSKHV\LQJ DQRUDFOHWKDW ¢MDFSL´«ALRY [TW@FWWW¯TLRY WKDWKLVVRQZLOOEHW\UDQW EXWQRWKLVVRQ VVRQV7KLVRIFRXUVH WXUQV RXWWREHWUXH+GWH  FRQVXOWV KLVGHDGZLIH0HOLVVDDWDQHFURPDQWHLRQ  3HULDQGHU WKHGHSRVLW RIDJXHVWIULHQG 0HOLVVDDWILUVW UHIXVHV WRDVVLVW KLP DERXW VKHLVFROGKHUFORWKHV XQEXUQW DWKHUIXQHUDO GRKHUQRJRRG  EHFDXVH ZKDWVKHVD\VLVWUXH 7RSURYH WKDW VKHRIIHUV WKHIDPRXV TXLS7HOO 3HULDQGHU KHEDNHGKLVORDYHVLQDFROGRYHQ ZKLFK 6RFOHVFKDUDFWHU RISURRIWKDW OLNHKDOIDVSOLWFRLQ L]HVDVDDX_X¡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«YU_ WRWKHPDWWHU KHFDQQRW OLNH7KXF\GLGHV $«eL© VXLWDEOH  JLYHXV WKHZHLJKW\ GHPDQGHG E\WKHFULVLV SROLWLFDO DUJXPHQW )RUPRUH UHFHQW RIWKHFRQWH[WXDO DQGVLJQLILFDQFH VFKRODUO\ UHFXSHUDWLRQV DGHTXDF\ RI6RFOHV VSHHFK DQG3ROLWLFDO&XOWXUH LQ$QFLHQW *UHHFH VHH-)0F*OHZ 7\UDQQ\ +HURGRWXV DQG,PDJHVRI7\UDQQ\ 7KH7\UDQWV RI ,WKDFD 9-*UD\ $-3  0:©FRZVNL ,URQLH HWKLVWRLUH /HGLVFRXUV GH &RULQWK +HURGRWXV  6RFOHV +«URGRWH 9  $QF6RF  ' 0 -RKQVRQ 6WRU\WHOOLQJ 6SHHFKHV6RFOHV  DQG/HRW\FKLGHV  &-  & )RUP DQG&RQWHQW 7KH4XHVWLRQ RI7\UDQQ\ LQ+HURGRWXV LQ.$0RUJDQ 'HZDOG DQG,WV'LVFRQWHQWV LQ$QFLHQW *UHHFH$XVWLQ HG3RSXODU7\UDQQ\ 7H[  6RYHUHLJQW\ )RUH[WHQGHG GLVFXVVLRQ RIWKHIXQFWLRQ RIRUDFOHVDVQDUUDWLYH VFDIIROGLQJ LQ6RFOHV VSHHFK VHHHVSHFLDOO\ ,ILQG XVHIXO DQGSHUVXDVLYH HV :©FRZVNL WKHDFFRXQWV RI:©FRZVNL DQG-RKQVRQ EXWQHLWKHU DGGUHVVHV 6RFOHV  SHFLDOO\ UHDOO\ REVHVVLRQ ZLWK RUDFXODU VRP\UHDGLQJ VHUYHV DVDFRPSOHPHQW WRWKHLUV LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ  $1RWHRQ&RQMHFWXUHV )RUWKLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ VHH3+RKWL (70%$$$(($,    LQ+HURGRWXV $UFWRV This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions  /(6/,(.85.( XQGHUVWDQGV KHUULGGOLQJ EXUQV DOOWKHIDQF\ FORWKHVRIWKH PHVVDJH &RULQWKLDQ ZRPHQIRU0HOLVVDDQGHYHQWXDOO\ KHUVKDGH JHWVIURP RQVHFRQGFRQVXOWDWLRQ WKHORFDWLRQ RIWKHORVWGHSRVLWUM  ZLWKRYYFRPSRXQGV WKDW )LQDOO\DIWHUD VSHHFKSHUPHDWHG WKH RI HYLGHQFH DQG W KH R I KXPDQ GHVLJQDWH SXWWLQJ WRJHWKHU SURFHVV 6RFOHVFRQFOXGHV LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ :HKDYHERUQHZLWQHVVLQYRNLQJ WKHJRGVRIWKH *UHHNV IRU\RXQRWWRHVWDEOLVK LQWKHFLW W\UDQQLHV LHV:LOO\RXWKHQ QRWFHDVHEXWFRQWLQXH WKHDWWHPSW WRMXVWLFHWRUHLQVWDWH FRQWUDU\ +LSSLDV".QRZWKDW WKH&RULQWKLDQV DWOHDVWGRQRWDVVHQWIRU\RX R» DXYDLYHRY[D©+GWUM  RQWKHQRWHRIFRPPXQDO DVVHQWRUUDWKHU WKHODFNWKHUHRI  (QGLQJ WKH&RULQWKLDQ WKHSRZHURIKXPDQ GHOLEHUDWLRQ WR GHOHJDWHDVVHUWV WKHYDOLGLW\ DQGZRUWK RIRUDFOHV $QGWKHDOOLHVHPEROG DGMXGLFDWH HQHGWRVSHHFKE\6RFOHV H[DPSOH KLVDFFRXQWRIRUDFXODU SUHIHU WUXWK WRWKH6SDUWDQV DOOHJDWLRQ RIFRXQWHUIHLW RUDFOHV¥QD© WL©  DL4HH[R WR½NRTOY*ORX WWMY\Y£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«©LR$X SUM_/LRY ´ª QHDUHVW $QGVRZKHQ WKH ªAHYHL.DY[D© WR  DVNWKHLU VDFUHGDPEDVVDGRUV UHWXUQHG WKH\ZHUHSUHVHQWLQJ 1RWLFHWKDWWKHWKHPH RIWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RIULGGOLQJ VLJQVWKDWSHUPHDWHV 6RFOHV QDUUDWLYH HYHQVHHPVWRLQIHFW WKHOHYHORIKXPDQKXPDQ LQ FRPPXQLFDWLRQ WKHWDOHRI7KUDV\EXOXVW\UDQQLFDO DGYLFHWR3HULDQGHU  +GW& UMO  -9 :LWKLQ IRXUDQGDKDOI 2&7SDJHVZHILQG DXYTM´µY RYX¡D$HR4DL RYYI .DY DXY«Y[H© DXYH¯© UM  DX_D¡R$DLRY+GWD +LSSLDV U WR6RFOHVDWWKLVSRLQWWKRXJK LWIDLOVWRSHUVXDGH WKHDO  HVSRQVH DILQDOLQVWDQFH RIGXHOOLQJ RUDFXODU DXWKRULWLHV OLHV UHSUHVHQWV +LSSLDVDQVZHUHG VDPHJRGVDVWKDW LQGHHG WKH&RULQWKLDQV PRVWRI KLP RQHWKDW FDOOLQJRQWKHYHU\ DOOZRXOGORQJIRU WKH3HLVLVWUDWLGV ZKHQHYHU WKHDSSRLQWHG WKHP WREH GD\VFDPHIRU $WKHQLDQV $QG+LSSLDV ZLWK WKHVH ZRUGV VLQFHKHNQHZ WKH DQQR\HG E\WKH UHVSRQGHG RUDFOHVPRVWDFFXUDWHO\ RIDOOPHQ+GW 1RWLFHKRZ+LSSLDV DVVHUWLRQ 7KH&RULQWKLDQV PRVWRIDOOZLOOORQJIRUWKH3HLVLVWUDWLGV ZKHQHYHU WKHDSSRLQWHG WKHIRUP RIDW\SLFDO RUDFXODU [ZLOOKDSSHQ ZKHQHYHU GD\VFRPHPLPHV UHVSRQVH \KDSSHQVVHH+GWDQGVHH)RQWHQURVH >DERYHQ@  This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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»\£©WLF[Dœ7UM© ¢MDH¯YDUY \YFRMDU  ª´•.HHSDLYHD¸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«©LR‚¼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his content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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¡D$$RMDeYRF  WKHZRUNLQJ DXYH¡D†$H[R WKH ZDVUHODWLQJ WKHULGGOLQJ DQGKDYLQJ RUDFOH JRQHEDFNWR6SDUWD L¥YW´ HQWLUH PDWWHU WRWKH/DFHGDHPRQLDQV ªFS©D&H $D.H´DL_DRY¯RLFQ WKHHQWLUH $WWKDW +GW  DVVHPEO\ SRLQW E\LPSOLFDWLRQ X4I \ LD /LFKDVHYHQWXDOO\ RIWKH/DFHGDHPRQLDQV JHWV E\ZKLFK SORWVWKHWULFN 6HH$OHVVDQGUL DERYHQO   ZKRDUJXHVWKDWZKDWPDNHVDOOWKUHHRI LVWKHIDLOXUHRIDSSOLFDWLRQRIKXPDQVRSKLD WRWKHLU +HURGRWXV RUDFOHV .L¡RUM$RF FLWLQJWKHSDUDOOHORI7KJQ  , FRQFXUZLWKWKLVEXWZRXOG LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ GLV HPSKDVL]HVRPHZKDWPRUHWKDQ$OHVVDQGULWKHSROLWLFDOGLPHQVLRQRIFRPPXQLW\ FXVVLRQDQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RIRUDFOHV This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions &RXQWHUIHLW2UDFOHV DQG/HJDO WHQGHU  WKHVHFRQG 7KXVLQWKLV KROGRI2UHVWHVERQHV  RUDFOH LQVWDQFH WKRXJK K XPDQ EHFDXVH LVQRWFRXQWHUIHLW LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ ULGGOLQJ .W¡RUM$RF  PDNHLWOHJDOWHQGHU DQGGHOLEHUDWLRQ WHOOVXV ,QWKHFDVHRI&URHVXV ULGGOLQJ RUDFOHWKHQDUUDWLYH DIWHU WKH F RXQWHUIHLW I DLOXUHV KRZ & URHVXV  :KHQ SURGXFHG H[SOLFLWO\ &URHVXV W R D OORZV WKHIDOORI6DUGLVWKHFRQTXHURU UHSURDFK &\UXV WKH3\WKLD WKH'HOSKLFRUDFOHZLWKKLVFKDLQV UHVSRQGV GRHV&URHVXV QRWULJKWO\ $VIRUWKHRUDFOHGHOLYHUHG LIKHZHUHWRPDNHDQ /R[LDVSUHGLFWHG EODPHLWIRU D KHZRXOGGHVWUR\ H[SHGLWLRQ DJDLQVWWKH3HUVLDQV ZHOO LI W RGHOLEHUDWH KHZDV %XW JRLQJ JUHDW HPSLUH HX D«$$RY[D ¡RX$HXHD*DW KH  RXJKWWRKDYHVHQW RUWKDW KHPHDQW KLVRZQHPSLUH DQGDVNHGZKHWKHU WKHWKLQJ RI&\UXV6LQFHKHQHLWKHU FRPSUHKHQGHG DVWKH VDLGQRUDVNHGDJDLQOHWKLPUHYHDOKLPVHOI RQHUHVSRQVLEOH +GW  KDYH WKDW KHVKRXOG L Q ZRUGV WHOOV & URHVXV VR W KH +HUH 3\WKLD PDQ\ LQDGGLWLRQ WR DVNHGWKHRUDFOHIRUFODULILFDWLRQ EXWLQWULJXLQJO\ DOVRJHVWXUHV IRUGLYLQHDLGWKH3\WKLD V LWVFOHDUPDQGDWH UHSURDFK LQWKHSDUWLFLSLDO GHOLEHUDWLRQ WKHHOHPHQW RIKXPDQ WRZDUG SKUDVH HX_/L«$$RY[D ZHOO  LIKHZDVJRLQJWRGHOLEHUDWH RX$HXHDD/ KLQW UHPLQGV XVWKDW &URHVXVKDG WKH3\WKLD V $QGVXUHHQRXJK ZKRZDVFRQVLGHUHG RQHRIWKH/\GLDQV UHFHLYHG VDJHDGYLFHIURP KDGDGYLVHGKLP 6DQGDQLV WREHZLVHQDPHG6DQGDQLV HYHQEHIRUH DXYH¡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¼´ ªQDYHLSµILHYR© R»DX$$D¡FRY FODXVHVRIWKHODVWVHQWHQFH SRVH TXRWHG DQGUHFRQVXOWDWLRQ RIWKHRUDFOHDVHTXLYD YLDKXPDQ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ FRPSUHKHQVLRQ RIYRLFHDQGYLVLRQLQWKLVODVWVHQWHQFH OHQWDOWHUQDWLYHV 1RWLFHDOVRWKHRSSRVLWLRQ UHVXOW RIKXPDQ GHOLEHUDWLRQ WKHRUDFOHLVW´4UM«YWKHWKLQJ VDLG ZKLOHWKHILQDO FRQVXOWDWLRQ LVVXPPHG DQGGLYLQH OHWKLPUHYHDO XSLQWKHLPSHUDWLYH ¢7LRFSDLY«[FR DVWKHRQHUHVSRQVLEOH  KLPVHOI This content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions  /HVOLH .XUNH RI 7KLVSDVVDJHHODERUDWHV DIDYRULWH +HURGRWHDQ WRSRVRIWKHFRQWUDVW WKHIDFWWKDW6DQGDQLV  EXWLWVW\SLFDOLW\ VKRXOGQRWREVFXUH QDWLRQV WKHULGGOH RIWKHRUDFOH KHZLOOGH DQVZHUV FRPSDULVRQ LPSOLFLWO\ +GW  DJUHDW .D[D$XDHLY VWUR\ HPSLUH_QH\£‚U ¯[T[WMY OLOY Y YRLFH )RU6DQGDQLV Z  RUGVLPPHGLDWHO\ FRQILUPHG E\WKHQDUUDWLYH ZKLOH F RQVWLWXWHV D PDNH FOHDU W KDW LWVHOI  /\GLD JUHDW WUDQVSDUHQWO\ IDLOVWRSXW WKH3HUVLDQV GRQRW\HWUDWHDVVXFK%XW&URHVXV HPSLUH WKLVDGYLFHWRJHWKHU ZLWKKLVRUDFOHDX_/L¡D$$R_XDLRU  FRPSUHKHQG LWVUHOHYDQFHDX†$D_D¡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his content downloaded from 169.229.32.36 on Sat, 03 Oct 2015 00:24:14 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions