Skip to main content

Rittenhouse Inn Wassail Punch

Image may contain Drink Alcohol Beer Beverage Food Dessert Cup Caramel and Coffee Cup
Rittenhouse Inn Wassail PunchSheri Giblin

Wassail is a deeply rooted tradition in the Midwest and a popular regional staple throughout the cold-weather season. Every winter as the holidays approach, many Wisconsinites still take part in the age-old "wassailing of apple trees," a ritual dating back to the fifteenth century that involves sprinkling wassail on apple trees to ensure a strong, healthy harvest and to keep the trees safe from evil spirits. Wassail always blends apples and winter holiday spices, but the sweeteners and spirits often change from recipe to recipe. This version comes from the Rittenhouse Inn in Bayfield, an area that leads apple production in Wisconsin. The cranberry juice is a perfectly tart counterpart to the sweetness of the apple cider and brown sugar, and the bourbon lends a full, rich quality, and the ginger, pepper, and spices offer a final kick of flavor.

Ingredients

Serves 10 to 12

Wassail:

12 whole cloves
6 whole allspice
1/2 inch fresh ginger root, peeled and sliced
3 cinnamon sticks
12 whole white peppercorns
1 gallon fresh apple cider
6 ounces cranberry juice
3/4 cup light brown sugar, packed
10-12 ounces bourbon

Tools:

cheesecloth, kitchen string, large pot

Glasses:

mugs

Garnish:

ground nutmeg and 1 cinnamon stick per drink

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    To make the wassail, wrap the cloves, allspice, ginger, cinnamon sticks, and peppercorns in cheesecloth and tie with kitchen string. Combine the cider, cranberry juice, brown sugar, and spice bag in a large pot over high heat. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer 30 minutes.

  2. Step 2

    For each serving, put one ounce of the bourbon into a mug and fill it with hot Wassail. Garnish with a dusting of nutmeg and a cinnamon stick.

Tip:

The Wassail can be stored for several days in a covered container in the refrigerator. If you like lots of spice, you can make it a day ahead and leave the spice bag in the container overnight.

From The American Cocktail: 50 Recipes that Celebrate the Craft of Mixing Drinks from Coast to Coast by the Editors of Imbibe Magazine. Text copyright © 2011 by Imbibe magazine; photographs copyright © 2011 by Sheri Giblin. Published by Chronicle Books.
Sign In or Subscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Rittenhouse Inn Wassail Punch?

Leave a Review

  • Made this last year, loved it! I'm adding this to my holiday traditions. :)

    • MyLadyNight

    • IN

    • 12/23/2012

  • I really loved this recipe because it reminds me of the Christmas parties back home in Iowa. I changed it up a bit. I added the bourbon to the pot to boil it with the cider. This makes the flavor stand out more to me and I can serve it to everybody this way. It has an amazing flavor and I actually make it year-round whenever I get a little homesick. I actually made this for CHristmas last year when my family came to visit and my grandmother, who usually makes it for our gatherings and is a proffessional chef, actually said that this was the best that she had ever had and wanted the recipe. I HIGHLY recommend this!

    • epauley7

    • Sugar Land, TX

    • 8/7/2012

  • Delicious! Made it with Pomegranate rather than cranberry juice and 1/2 c. brown sugar since the honey crisp cider I had is fairly sweet on its own. Served with bourbon and dark spiced rum on the side so folks could choose if & how much they wanted to add (but it’s also excellent without alcohol.) Serving with the cinnamon sticks is a festive touch. Everyone wanted the recipe - this punch is a new family holiday tradition! :-)

    • JayWo

    • Northern Virginia

    • 12/22/2022

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips

Read More
Forget lackluster loaves—apple cider brings big autumnal flavor to this tender pumpkin bread.
Cinnamon and brown sugar bring warm flavor to this puffy, large-format apple pancake.
This ginger-stout cake from famed pastry chef Claudia Fleming gets generous layers of buttermilk frosting, with the sides of the cake left au naturel.
This maple-sweetened, wheat-free pumpkin pie is perfectly creamy with a toasty, comforting oat-flour crust.
Jammed with mix-ins, including dried sour cherries, these flourless oatmeal cookies are wholesome and chunky with a warm, rounded hint of cinnamon.
Ideal for starting the night, this cozy concoction blends apple cider with a hint of burnt orange and rosemary.
With less sugar and more salt than most other recipes, this buttery, toasted crumb crust is significantly nicer than anything store-bought.
Cowboy cookies are like oatmeal ones, but packed with hearty mix-ins like coconut, pecans, and chocolate.