Aesop
|
Greece

The Dog in The Manger

A dog in the manger growls at the ox despite having no interest in the hay, until its owner scolds it for its selfishness.
Greed
Generosity
Responsibility
Aesop's Fables - The Dog in The Manger
Audio available for B1 version

Once, there was a dog that had taken rest in a manger filled with hay. When an ox approached the manger to eat the hay, the dog growled and barked, preventing the ox from having any of it.

Despite having no interest in the hay, the dog was unwilling to share it with the ox. This continued for some time until the ox gave up and left the manger empty-handed.

The dog, however, remained in the manger and continued to lie on the hay, even though it couldn't eat it. The dog was determined not to let anyone else have it.

Eventually, the owner of the manger noticed what was happening and scolded the dog for its selfish behavior, saying, "You have no use for the hay, yet you are stopping others from having it. Don't prevent others from having what you don't need!"

Feeling ashamed, the dog left the manger, allowing other animals to eat the hay.

Once, there was a dog. The dog was lying in a place full of dry grass for animals to eat. When an ox came to eat the grass, the dog made loud and angry sounds. It did not let the ox eat the grass.

The dog did not want to eat the grass. But it did not let the ox eat it either. This happened many times. The ox walked away with nothing to eat.

The dog stayed on the grass. It could not eat the grass. But it did not move. The dog did not want others to have the grass.

After some time, the person who owned the place saw this. He was not happy with the dog. He said, "You don't eat the grass. But you don't let others eat it. Do not stop others from having what you don't need!"

The dog felt bad. It left the place. Then, other animals could eat the grass.

Once upon a time, there was a dog that decided to rest in a manger full of hay. When an ox came close to the manger to eat some of the hay, the dog started to growl and bark loudly, making sure the ox couldn't eat any of it.

Even though the dog didn't want to eat the hay itself, it didn't want the ox to have any either. This went on for a while until the ox finally walked away without getting any hay.

The dog stayed in the manger, lying on the hay it didn't need. It was very determined not to share with anyone.

After a while, the person who owned the manger saw what was happening. He told off the dog for being so selfish. He said, "You don't need the hay, but you won't let others have it. You shouldn't stop others from using what you don't need!"

Feeling embarrassed, the dog left the manger. This allowed the other animals to finally eat the hay.

Once upon a time, in a cozy barn filled with hay, there was a dog who thought he'd found the perfect spot for a nap. "Ah, this hay is just right! Comfy and cozy, like pajamas for my fur," he thought.

Now, along came an ox, who looked at the hay and said, "Yum! Dinner time!" But the dog quickly growled, "No, no, no! This is my bed, not your snack!"

The ox tilted his head, confused, "But you don't eat hay, do you?"

The dog wagged his tail and said, "Eat it? No way! But I like to sleep on it. It's like a big, scratchy blanket!"

The ox tried to reason with the dog, "But I'm hungry, and you're lying on my dinner!"

The dog barked back, wagging his tail, "Oh no, you don't! You'll have to find something else. This hay is mine, all mine! It's my fluffy bed, like sleeping on a cloud made of noodles!"

The ox tried and tried, but the dog wouldn't budge. He was as stubborn as a ticklish turtle. The ox left the manger, still hungry, and the dog chuckled to himself, "That'll show him!"

Eventually, the owner of the manger noticed what was happening and said to the dog, "You silly pup! You don't need this hay, so why not share? It's like having a mountain of toys and not letting anyone play with them!"

The dog's ears went floppy, and he realized he'd been a bit selfish. Feeling sorry, he said, "You're right. I don't need all this hay. Sharing is like giving a big, happy hug!"

And with that, the dog left the manger, and the other animals were free to eat the hay.

With a wag and a bark in a farmyard one day,
Lay a dog in a manger where bundles of hay,
Were stored for the oxen, their dinner and meal,
But the dog found the manger a comfortable steal.

Up came an ox with a hunger and thirst,
To the hay in the manger it wandered at first,
But the dog with a growl and a menacing glare,
Told the ox, "You won't eat any hay from there!"

"But why?" asked the ox, with a puzzled frown,
"You can't eat the hay, won't you let me chow down?"
But the dog wouldn't budge, it refused to comply,
"Though I don't eat the hay, you won't get it, oh my!"

Day after day, the scene was the same,
The dog and the ox, in this selfishness game,
The ox would come hungry, the dog would say "Nay!",
And the ox would leave, empty and sullen each day.

But a farmer, the owner, a wise man indeed,
Saw what was happening, took careful heed,
He scolded the dog with a stern voice and eye,
"You don't need the hay, why make the ox cry?"

Ashamed and embarrassed, the dog slunk away,
Leaving the manger and bundles of hay,
The ox could now eat, and the farm was at peace,
And the selfish old dog had caused trouble to cease.

Share
Feedback

Word Finder

  1. Ox

    Big animal used on farms, similar to a cow.

  2. Loud

    Making a lot of noise.

  3. Angry

    Feeling or showing upset or annoyance.

  4. Owned

    Something that belongs to someone.

  5. Person

    A human being.

  6. Either

    One or the other of two.

  7. Felt

    Experienced an emotion.

  8. Dry

    Not wet or moist.

  9. Let

    Allow to do something.

  10. Place

    A particular area or location.

  1. Manger

    A container animals eat from.

  2. Hay

    Dry grass for feeding animals.

  3. Growl

    Low, rough sound animals make when angry.

  4. Bark

    Loud sound a dog makes.

  5. Ox

    A large animal used for work on farms.

  6. Determined

    Very decided and not giving up.

  7. Selfish

    Thinking only about yourself, not others.

  8. Embarrassed

    Feeling ashamed or shy.

  9. Share

    To let others use or have some of what you have.

  10. Owned

    Something belongs to someone.

Understanding Questions

  1. Where was the dog lying?

    1. In a river
    2. In a place full of dry grass
    3. In a tree
    4. In a house
  2. What did the ox want to do?

    1. Play with the dog
    2. Sleep on the grass
    3. Eat the grass
    4. Swim in a pond
  3. What did the dog do when the ox came to eat the grass?

    1. It played with the ox.
    2. It made loud and angry sounds.
    3. It went to sleep.
    4. It helped the ox eat the grass.
  4. Why was the person who owned the place not happy with the dog?

    1. The dog was eating all the grass.
    2. The dog did not let others eat the grass.
    3. The dog was too loud.
    4. The dog was sleeping too much.
  5. What happened after the dog left the place?

    1. The grass disappeared.
    2. Other animals could not eat the grass.
    3. Other animals could eat the grass.
    4. The ox went to sleep.
  1. What action did the dog take when the ox tried to eat some hay from the manger?
  2. Why did the dog not allow the ox to eat the hay, despite not needing it for itself?
  3. What was the consequence of the dog's actions for the ox?
  4. How did the owner of the manger react when he saw what the dog was doing?
  5. What was the outcome for the dog after the owner scolded it for its behavior?
  1. What was the initial action of the dog in the stable, and how did it impact the ox's intention to feed on the hay?
  2. Describe the dog's behavior towards the ox when it approached the manger and the rationale behind such behavior.
  3. Explain the outcome of the standoff between the dog and the ox, including any actions taken by the ox as a result.
  4. What was the reaction of the manger's owner upon discovering the situation between the dog and the ox, and what specific criticism did he levy against the dog?
  5. After the owner's reprimand, what change occurred in the dog's actions, and what was the immediate effect of this change on the other animals?

Reflection Questions

  1. Why do you think the dog didn't want the ox to eat the hay, even though he didn't want to eat it himself?
  2. How do you think the ox felt when the dog wouldn't let him eat the hay? How would you feel in the ox's place?
  3. Can you recall a time when you didn't want to share something, even though you weren't using it?
  4. What is the lesson that the dog learned from the owner of the manger and how does this lesson apply to our own lives?
  5. Why is it important to let others use things that we don't need? Can you think of a way you could share something you don't use often with someone who could benefit from it?

Fable Quotes

Don't keep what you don't need, for denying others is a selfish deed.
Sharing the unneeded is a simple act of generosity.
Don't guard what isn't yours; others may need it more.
About

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere.