Race vs Ethnicity: Race and Ethnicity terms are used to categorize the sections of the population. When we divide people into groups of difference between Race and Ethnicity, based on their physical characteristics, it is referred to as race. Ethnicity refers to the Cultural Differences & identification of people of different geographic regions, including their customs, history, language & religion. So basically, race describes physical traits while ethnicity refers to cultural identification.
While filling out an application form, we might be asked about the race, or ethnicity, that we identify with. But how are these terms, race & ethnicity different from each other? These terms are often interchangeably used. They are not the same thing. Race is biological, describing physical traits inherited from one’s parents. Ethnicity is an individual’s cultural identity, chosen or learned from his/her culture & family.
Difference Between Race and Ethnicity
Difference between Race and Ethnicity
Race is a sociological designation that identifies a group sharing some outward physical characteristics & some similarities within culture & history. On the other hand, Ethnicity tends to give us an idea about our nationality, heritage, culture, ancestry & upbringing. The difference between Race and Ethnicity are shown below:
|
Ethnicity refers to the cultural expression & identification of people of different geographic regions, including their customs, history, language & religion.
|
Race refers to a group of people who are connected by a common descent or origin.
|
|
It means shared cultural traits & a shared group history. Also there are some ethnic groups which share linguistic or religious traits, & some others share a common group history but not a common language or religion.
|
Race presumes shared biological or genetic traits.
|
|
Ethnicity is defined in terms of shared genealogy. If people believe they descend from a particular group & they want to be associated with that group, then they are in fact members of that group.
|
Due to geographical isolation, racial categories result from a shared genealogy. However, today the racial groups have mixed.
|
|
Ethnic groups distinguish themselves differently from time to time. They seek to define themselves but are defined by the stereotypes of dominant groups.
|
Its assumed that races are distinguished by skin color, facial type, etc. Scientific studies show that racial genetic differences are weak except in skin color.
|
|
In 19th century, political ideology of ethnic nationalism came up. Nations were created based on a presumed shared ethnic origins (e.g. Germany, Italy, Sweden…)
|
The concept of nationalism was often used to justify the domination of one race over another within a specific nation, in 19th century.
|
|
In the last decades of the 20th century, in the U.S. & in most nations, the legal system & official ideology prohibits ethnic-based discrimination.
|
In the last decades of the 20th century, the legal system & the official ideology puts emphasis on racial equality.
|
|
Throughout history, brutal conflicts between ethnic groups have occurred. But its also seen how in most nations, most ethnic groups do get along peacefully with one another.
|
Racial prejudice continues to be an issue. In the 21st century, fewer race-based conflicts happen.
|
|
Conflict between Tamil & Sinhalese populations in Sri Lanka.
|
Conflict between White & African-American people in the U.S., especially during the civil rights movement.
|
Check-out: What are the challenges to Cultural Diversity?
Comprehensive Comparison Between Race vs Ethnicity
While race and ethnicity are often used interchangeably, they are distinct concepts:
- Race is primarily associated with physical characteristics. It is a socially constructed category that has been used historically to categorize people based on physical attributes like skin color, facial features, and hair texture. Races are often seen as broad categories such as Caucasian, African, Asian, etc.
- Ethnicity, on the other hand, refers to cultural factors. It encompasses language, nationality, religion, and other cultural elements. For example, Jewish people may be considered an ethnic group, sharing common cultural traditions, religious beliefs, and language, despite having varied physical appearances.
The distinction between race and ethnicity becomes clear when considering individuals of the same race who may belong to different ethnic groups. For example, an African American and a Kenyan may share similar racial characteristics but have vastly Cultural Differences, languages, and traditions.
Read: What Is Critical Race Theory (CRT)
What is Race?
Around 1490–1500, for the first time the word ‘Race’ was used. It simply refers to group of people who are connected by a common descent or origin. Example: the English Race, or English people. By 1700s, the word ‘race’ acquired a different meaning. With the spread of European Colonialism & Imperialism, White Europeans used race to classify humans by their place of origin & skin color. The foundation of slavery came to be based upon this social hierarchy. It was seen that people whose race appeared to be white believed the color of their skin & other aspects of their appearance meant they were more intelligent, moral, capable—more human—than those who were not white. The whites believed they were superior than others.
Classifying people based on their color & then deciding who is better, is not right. People should be classified based on their nature, personality, knowledge, abilities, talent & other skills. However, the idea of race can be very meaningful to certain people—especially those members of minority groups who have been marginalized & oppressed. They may associate race with cultural importance. In the present times, we see how American music artists like Beyoncé & Jennifer Lopez celebrate their race & heritage through their work. However, even today, people often tend to confuse race with ethnicity.
Examples of Race
Few examples of the racial categories we see around us, are :
- White or Caucasian – British, French, German, etc.
- Black – Kenyan, Nigerian, Somalian, etc.
- American Indian or Alaska Native – Iroquois, Cherokee, Navajo, Haida, etc.
- Latino or Hispanic – Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, etc.
- Asian – Japanese, Korean, Chinese, Cambodian, etc.
- Pacific Islander or Hawaiian – Samoan, Tongan, Maori, Tahitian, etc.
Check-out: Diversity in India
What is Ethnicity?
Ethnicity refers to the cultural expression & identification of people of different geographic regions, including their customs, history, language & religion. Ethnicity is about finding out & learning what group of people you identify with as per common racial, national, tribal, religious, linguistic, or cultural origin or background. It tends to give us an idea about our nationality, heritage, culture, ancestry & upbringing.
We must remember that people may have racial similarity but ethnic dissimilarity.
The term ethnicity began to be used much later, around 1765–75. Let’s see what defines ethnicity.
- Language – Ethnicity is linked with the language one speaks, like Hindi, which means representation of a shared cultural history among those who speak the language.
- Nationality – It is also associated with one’s relations to a specific nation, such as India.
- Religious expression – Ethnicity can also be associated with a religion, especially when there are social similarities & longstanding cultural practices involved, as in Judaism or Islam.
Examples of Ethnicity
Some major examples of ethnicity include:
- Arabs – Populate such countries as Algeria, Sudan, Iraq & Saudi Arabia, mostly Muslim
- American Indian or Alaska Native – Iroquois, Cherokee, Navajo, Haida, etc.
- Irish – Catholic religion, traditions like St. Patrick’s Day
- Italian – Largest ethnic group in Italy
- Jewish – Judaism religion, languages like Yiddish & Hebrew, originated from Israelites
- French – Unique traditions like All Souls’ Day & St. Catherine’s Day
- Han Chinese – Largest ethnic group in China & worldwide
- Caribbean – Jamaica, Trinidad, Bahamas, etc.
- Russian – Celebrate Orthodox & pagan traditions, including Maslenitsa
- Korean – Celebrate Seollal (Lunar New Year’s Day) & Hansik (Eating Cold Food Day), some celebrate birthdays on lunar calendar
- Swedish – Traditions like Swedish National Day
- Dutch – From the Netherlands, original traditions like National Queen’s Day
- Japanese – Sports such as sumo wrestling
- Greeks – Traditions like “name day” & Apokries (Carnival)
- African – Tribal origins, multiple Afro-languages & cultures
Importance of Race and Ethnicity
When people misunderstand race and ethnicity, it can cause problems in society. Misconceptions often lead to unfair treatment and barriers between different groups. It affects laws, policies, and politics, sometimes causing divisions and biases because of these wrong ideas.
Check-out: Culture – Definition, Characteristics, Factors & Significance
However, clearing up these misunderstandings can make society better. When we work to understand different cultures and challenge unfair ideas, we create a more understanding and respectful society. People feel more connected, and diverse cultures become something to appreciate. Fixing these misunderstandings is the first step to a world where differences enrich society, making it more inclusive and aware of different cultures.
Challenges Surrounding Race and Ethnicity
There are issues with how people use race and ethnicity. Sometimes, these labels get simplified or used the wrong way, leading to misunderstandings and supporting stereotypes. This misuse can cause discrimination and biases, turning these terms into tools that divide people instead of bringing understanding. There’s also disagreement about which groups should be part of certain racial or ethnic categories, causing arguments and tensions.
- To make a fair society, it’s important to deal with stereotypes linked to race and ethnicity.
- To do this, we need education, open talks, and changing long-held misunderstandings.
- It’s helpful to highlight the differences and diversity among racial and ethnic groups, breaking stereotypes and building understanding.
- Also, when we encourage cultural understanding and being sensitive to others, it helps reduce biases by making people value different cultures and backgrounds. All these efforts work towards creating a more inclusive society.
Check-out: Accommodation of Social Diversity
Real-Life Examples and Updated Statistics
Race and ethnicity play a pivotal role in shaping our society. For instance, the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2020 report highlights that approximately 18.5% of the American population identifies as Hispanic or Latino, a clear indication of the country’s ethnic diversity. Meanwhile, African Americans, who are often categorized based on race, make up about 13.4% of the population.
Racial Identity: In recent times, the Black Lives Matter movement has brought to the forefront the profound impact of racial identity on social dynamics. This movement underscores the experiences of African Americans and the systemic racial disparities they face, from law enforcement to employment opportunities.
On the other hand, the celebration of cultural events like the Chinese New Year in various parts of the world, including the United States and Canada, showcases the richness of ethnic diversity. These celebrations are not just limited to people of Chinese descent but are embraced by various ethnicities, highlighting the inclusive nature of ethnic cultural practices.
Way Forward – Race vs Ethnicity
Thus we see how the terms, ‘Race’ & ‘Ethnicity’ came into being. Their origins, how they came to be interchangeably used over the years & how people still fail to notice the difference between the two. How societies & nations are filled up with various ethnicities. There may be two individuals who identify with the same ethnicity, but belong to different racial groups. Or how a person who may identify as part of a particular ethnic group, may have a different nationality.
However, people still tend to be confused between the two.
- Race simply refers to group of people who are connected by a common descent or origin.
- Ethnicity refers to the cultural expression & identification of people of different geographic regions, including their customs, history, language & religion. So basically, race describes physical traits while ethnicity refers to cultural identification.
In today’s world, discussing race & ethnicity is a sensitive issue. Based on the various opportunities & challenges faced by each group, several issues lead to the differences. There is ongoing research on race & ethnicity. Even though one group of scholars explain the origin of humanity through the European perspective, other scholars use the African version. The challenge lies in the fact that none of these can explain the differences amongst the various races.
In today’s times, race & ethnicity is usually associated with political & economic inequalities. Many indigenous people like the Native American, the Aboriginal people of Australia suffer much discrimination. Other minority groups like Hispanics & African Americans are poor & do not get adequate medical healthcare facilities.
Social institutions can help in analyzing & developing models for people to look at the variations & ensure equality.
Over the years, both the terms ”race” & ”ethnicity” & their definitions have underwent changes. We should never treat anyone as a superior or as an inferior race. Classifying people based on their color & then deciding who is better, is not right. People should be classified based on their nature, personality, knowledge, abilities, talent & other skills.
Related Resources:
FAQs on Race vs. Ethnicity
1. What is the difference between race and ethnicity?
Race generally refers to physical characteristics passed down through generations, while ethnicity relates to cultural expression and identification. Race is often perceived as biological, whereas ethnicity is linked to cultural identity.
2. Can you give examples of race and ethnicity?
Examples of race include categories like Caucasian, African, or Asian. Ethnicity examples include Irish, Cherokee, or Han Chinese, which refer to cultural groups.
3. Why is understanding the difference between race and ethnicity important?
Understanding these differences is crucial for appreciating the diversity of human experiences and for addressing issues related to social justice, discrimination, and cultural identity.
4. How is race classified in the United States Census?
The U.S. Census classifies race into several categories, including White, Black or African American, American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, and Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander.
5. Can a person belong to more than one ethnic group?
Yes, individuals can identify with multiple ethnic groups, reflecting the diverse cultural heritages and experiences that shape their identity.
6. How do race and ethnicity impact societal experiences?
Race and ethnicity can significantly influence an individual’s life experiences, including opportunities, social interactions, and perceptions by others in society.
7. Are race and ethnicity static categories?
The concepts of race and ethnicity are not static; they evolve over time and can vary across different societies and cultural contexts.
8. How do race and ethnicity relate to nationality?
Nationality refers to a person’s legal relationship with a state and does not necessarily correspond to their race or ethnicity, which are more about identity and cultural background.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Please Login to comment...